Monday started out really early, about 6:30 for breakfast in the hotel dining room. I'm not sure but they seem to be the slowest restaurant I've ever been in, even coffee takes 10-15 minutes. The other side of it was that even though our minder said she wanted to be going by 7:30 it was really closer to 8:30 by the time we actually left.
We drove to a small town a few miles from Cobán, San Juan Chamelco, where the head offices of Food for the Hungry are located and met the local Director Shane Hoffner and his wife Cali. They are both young and just learning Spanish, but seemed very dedicated and competent. His background is Civil Engineering and hers is Health Promotion, so they have good backgrounds for their work. We were only in the office for a few minutes and I was racing around to get the supplies for my had washing demonstration. We had purchased some soap and nylon stockings to put the soap in the night before and a bottle to use for the “tippytap” demonstration. Then we all piled back into the van for a trip on a very rough road to a small mountain community where the health promotion was taking place.
When we arrived they were already involved in the program, with a very animated woman giving an pep talk on hand washing to about 60 ladies from the area. She was speaking in the local native indian language and the woman were paying very close attention and responding to her talk. She was in modern dress but the audience women were all dressed in very elaborate, traditional costumes There were many that were hand embroidered, and some in traditional styles but using modern materials. The clothes were beautiful and I took a number of photos of them, which they seemed to be proud to pose for.
After the lady spoke, Cali, Shane's wife spoke. She is a beginning Spanish speaker but gamely gave a talk about hand washing and children, then did the old trick of putting hand lotion on her hands then glitter. Then by shaking hands with another person, some of the glitter and lotion came off on that persons hands who shook anothers hands and glitter came off again and the third person, and so on. It's a simple but effective game to play to demonstrate how bacteria are transferred from person to person. Next I did my demonstration with my water bottle. We used the same ladies to show that washing can remove the glitter/bacteria. I spoke in Spanish then someone translated it into the Indian dialect. It went okay, but my point was that it didn't use much water, and most of the women in the audience had running water in their homes and didn't need to conserve. It rains a lot and there are lots of springs so many villages have some sort of water system. The part about washing the glitter off their hands made more sense to them, it had a practical purpose. In all, I thought my presentation was sort of lame next to the ladies talk. She then followed my with an elaborate skit about a baby with diarrhea and had everyone's complete attention.
After I spoke I set up the solar stove outside to try it out. In my rush to get going I didn't bring a small pot so the one I ended up with was too large to heat up the water quickly, but the outside of the pot got hot. The ladies were really interested and crowded around wanting to know how it worked, so Susan and I took turns explaining it. That turned out to be the big hit of the day, so that was good. There is a lot of cloudy weather and rain and many people feel that a solar stove can only be a backup to wood burning. There is quite a lot of deforestation going on so that is a big issue.
Stan Withee was there looking at the water system. They have a chlorination system there but it doesn't work very well and they don't know how to manage it. Stan collected a sample for me to test for bacteria.
After that Stan and Shane were going out to look at a couple of other water systems and asked if I wanted to go along. With such short notice Susan and I had to race around to get our stuff collected and we got scattered . I ended up leaving my pack with my water bottle and laptop with Susan and took off in the van. We went to another community further up the road. They had a system where they had to pump water up to a high distribution tank. It was very expensive to run and didn't provide enough water for the people. The question was whether the pumps were working right or whether there were leaks in the system.
We hiked up the whole length of the pipe through very dense brush to measure the distance to the upper tank. The local men guided us up the hill, chopping the brush with machetes. There were beautiful flowers and plants everywhere but it was a struggle and very slippery and muddy from the rain. On top we took GPS measurements of the elevation and checked the tank. Everything seemed to be okay with their water system. Stan offered advice to them about simple things like making sure there were no leaking water faucets at peoples homes, or that they make sure they don't overfill the tanks and waste water they have pumped. He also examined their pumps to see that they were working adequately.
I thought that they had a very sophisticated and complicated system for such a small community, but that they seemed very comfortable with running it.
We then looked at another community even further up the road at a higher elevation. Our van couldn't climb the steep road and so we ended up walking up to the houses. There was no electricity there and the only year round functioning spring was below the homes, and it was small so there was no opportunity to pump adequate water up to the homes. The best that Stan could offer was to do a simple survey to show where the water pipe could be brought out to the edge of the road so that they could have a more convenient tank to store their water. Also we made suggestions about how to fence off the area to keep animals out and to cover the spring so that mud and debris didn't get into the water. We also took a sample to check for bacteria.
We finally got back to Cobán about 6 pm. I was really tired and muddy from all the climbing, plus I had several water samples to set up and incubate. It had been a long day, but it was fun. We rested for a while and took showers and got to bed about 11. I'm still concerned about my workshop on Thursday and need to go to the mercado to look for stove parts to build a rocket stove for a demonstration. I hope we will have time on Tuesday to look.
Tuesday, October 26, 2010
Sunday, October 24, 2010
Cobán
On Sunday morning we had a nice breakfast at the small pension where we stayed. It was a little distance from the airport and the streets are a little rough and confusing so I don't know exactly where we were. After breakfast we went to look at a different hotel that Roger Capps group will be staying in when they arrive. It really didn't look very clean so then we went to another hotel that our guide from Medical Teams recommended. It was really much better and about the same price so I wrote to Roger and to the person from Child Aid who is in charge of his trip with that info.
Guatemala City is large and spread out like Mexico City but seems to lack attractive central areas like parks or plazas. At least I didn't see any as we drove through town on our way out to Cobán. Cobán is about 4 or 5 hours away in the mountains. The climate is cooler and cloudier, sort of like Oregon but with a few palm trees. We passed through an area known as a bioreserve where some species of birds and plants are protected, like the Quetzal, Guatemala's national bird.
Near the bioreserve is a hotel resort complex called the Park Hotel. It's where we are going to have my workshop on Thursday and Friday. It's very nice and upscale, the fanciest place I've held a workshop. It's a little intimidating, I hope we get enough people to justify the expense.
In Cobán we met up with Stan Withee my teammate. He's been here a week surveying water systems in the small communities. He's a water engineer and has been climbing up and down the hills laying out pipe lines and examining springs and other water sources. He has a number of water samples for me to test so that he can report back to the people he helped.
Apparently we are scheduled to go to a health fair tomorrow in a community. The first part is a talk from a health nurse about hand washing and I suggested that we bring a hand washing station – called a tippytap- to show. It's just a plastic bottle with a few holes in it, plus a soap in a nylon stocking, but it works very well and is a good demonstration. In Mexico I gave out small geraniums with the tippytap which made them much more desirable. I'd thought about including it in the Friday lecture, so I guess I can try out my speech tomorrow.
In the afternoon I'm supposed to take some water samples as a demonstration for the community and bring the results back the next day. The only problem is that it sometimes takes more than 24 hours so I hope I have some results to show.
I've still got a ton of unpacking to do to get ready for tomorrow, so I'll sign off.
Let me know if you're reading this blog, and what your opinions are.
tom
Guatemala City is large and spread out like Mexico City but seems to lack attractive central areas like parks or plazas. At least I didn't see any as we drove through town on our way out to Cobán. Cobán is about 4 or 5 hours away in the mountains. The climate is cooler and cloudier, sort of like Oregon but with a few palm trees. We passed through an area known as a bioreserve where some species of birds and plants are protected, like the Quetzal, Guatemala's national bird.
Near the bioreserve is a hotel resort complex called the Park Hotel. It's where we are going to have my workshop on Thursday and Friday. It's very nice and upscale, the fanciest place I've held a workshop. It's a little intimidating, I hope we get enough people to justify the expense.
In Cobán we met up with Stan Withee my teammate. He's been here a week surveying water systems in the small communities. He's a water engineer and has been climbing up and down the hills laying out pipe lines and examining springs and other water sources. He has a number of water samples for me to test so that he can report back to the people he helped.
Apparently we are scheduled to go to a health fair tomorrow in a community. The first part is a talk from a health nurse about hand washing and I suggested that we bring a hand washing station – called a tippytap- to show. It's just a plastic bottle with a few holes in it, plus a soap in a nylon stocking, but it works very well and is a good demonstration. In Mexico I gave out small geraniums with the tippytap which made them much more desirable. I'd thought about including it in the Friday lecture, so I guess I can try out my speech tomorrow.
In the afternoon I'm supposed to take some water samples as a demonstration for the community and bring the results back the next day. The only problem is that it sometimes takes more than 24 hours so I hope I have some results to show.
I've still got a ton of unpacking to do to get ready for tomorrow, so I'll sign off.
Let me know if you're reading this blog, and what your opinions are.
tom
Saturday, October 23, 2010
First Night in Guatemala City
Susan and I arrive here in Guatemala City after a nice flight from Portland to Houston and then on to here. We'll stay overnight here and leave in the morning for Cobán, about four hours away by bus. It's supposed to be a beautiful place with lots of flowers and birds, including the Quetzal, the national bird. It's a sort of beautiful parrot with a long trailing tail.
I talked yesterday about the very short time we'll actually be here, just two weeks to visit many different small communities. I don't like that in one way, I don't want to be a visiting authority who comes in for a short visit, doesn't really understand the situation or the communities needs, makes some pronouncements and leaves. I'm going to try and not make myself seem all knowing and smarter than I really am. I'm expecting to learn more than I teach.
Someone once made a good observation to me that I really liked. When Americans volunteer for service projects like the one Susan and I are on, we sometimes think of ourselves as knowing a lot and coming to teach others who know less than us. We are on a higher plane and the people we are serving are down on a lower level. We are going to hand down our wisdom and the people will gratefully accept it. It's certainly easy to think like that when you see extreme poverty and illness, especially if you think you know ways to alleviate it.
That person put it differently. He said that instead it was more like a mutual sharing. That these people had ideas and skills just as valuable to teach us. He tells the people that he is working with that Americans need help, they need the skills and values that they have and that the Americans are coming to learn from them. Americans have lost the sense of family, the sense of sharing and community that these people have and they need the lessons that they can teach. That is a trade, not a one way transfer and no charity is involved.
When the interaction between volunteer groups and local communities is seen in that way, there is more of a mutual respect and sense of value in what each offers. I try to keep that observation in my mind at all times, and I try to listen more than I talk. I've certainly learned a lot about people and human values on the trips I have done, and I've hoped to share a little of what I know that can help someone else.
I'm really looking forward to this new learning experience!
Tom
I talked yesterday about the very short time we'll actually be here, just two weeks to visit many different small communities. I don't like that in one way, I don't want to be a visiting authority who comes in for a short visit, doesn't really understand the situation or the communities needs, makes some pronouncements and leaves. I'm going to try and not make myself seem all knowing and smarter than I really am. I'm expecting to learn more than I teach.
Someone once made a good observation to me that I really liked. When Americans volunteer for service projects like the one Susan and I are on, we sometimes think of ourselves as knowing a lot and coming to teach others who know less than us. We are on a higher plane and the people we are serving are down on a lower level. We are going to hand down our wisdom and the people will gratefully accept it. It's certainly easy to think like that when you see extreme poverty and illness, especially if you think you know ways to alleviate it.
That person put it differently. He said that instead it was more like a mutual sharing. That these people had ideas and skills just as valuable to teach us. He tells the people that he is working with that Americans need help, they need the skills and values that they have and that the Americans are coming to learn from them. Americans have lost the sense of family, the sense of sharing and community that these people have and they need the lessons that they can teach. That is a trade, not a one way transfer and no charity is involved.
When the interaction between volunteer groups and local communities is seen in that way, there is more of a mutual respect and sense of value in what each offers. I try to keep that observation in my mind at all times, and I try to listen more than I talk. I've certainly learned a lot about people and human values on the trips I have done, and I've hoped to share a little of what I know that can help someone else.
I'm really looking forward to this new learning experience!
Tom
Thursday, October 21, 2010
Guatemala Health Survey
It's been a while since I last posted on this blog, I usually try to focus on my current activities and projects. My wife Susan and I are leaving on Saturday, October 23 for Guatemala for a month of work. We are scheduled to meet with representatives of two organizations, Medical Teams International and Food for the Hungry. We'll be staying with them and helping do a health survey in a number of small communities is the central highlands of Guatemala.
Nearly two million children world wide die annually from drinking contaminated water. Most of my interest is is simple, low tech things families can do for themselves to make their water safe and protect their own health. Others can promote larger scale programs like wells and water systems, but I find that these projects are often expensive and complicated and a long time coming. Meanwhile children and families suffer from easily preventable diseases.
The kinds of questions I'll be asking include how many of the families have an adequate latrine or toilet. How is the drinking water in the community and has it been tested for contamination. How do families cook their meals, and what do they use, gas?, charcoal? wood? What is their overall health like.
The next questions are about what do the people there see as problems and what would they like to change? What are their priorities? Also, are there positive things about their communities and their lives that they want to preserve?
Then the question is what are their resources to make changes. Can the community help with money or labor? Is there leadership in the community to guide the work to completion? What about long term follow up?
I try not to impose my ideas on the people I'm working with, but try to understand their concerns and offer suggestions if asked. I'm hoping rather for discussions about their interests and their ideas about solutions. I can then perhaps offer different ideas that they could consider.
We'll see how all this will go! On top of all the logistical, cultural and language barriers there will only be a short amount of time to actually talk to people and listen to their ideas. I expect that I will get far more out of the visit than the people I meet. Hopefully I'll be able to bring back some ideas and perhaps develop some ideas for future projects.
In addition to working and report writing, I'll try to maintain this blog of my activities and I'll be happy to hear opinions from you about what I'm doing. You can also check out my Agua Pura website at http://aguapuraparaelpueblo.org/
watertestingTom
Nearly two million children world wide die annually from drinking contaminated water. Most of my interest is is simple, low tech things families can do for themselves to make their water safe and protect their own health. Others can promote larger scale programs like wells and water systems, but I find that these projects are often expensive and complicated and a long time coming. Meanwhile children and families suffer from easily preventable diseases.
The kinds of questions I'll be asking include how many of the families have an adequate latrine or toilet. How is the drinking water in the community and has it been tested for contamination. How do families cook their meals, and what do they use, gas?, charcoal? wood? What is their overall health like.
The next questions are about what do the people there see as problems and what would they like to change? What are their priorities? Also, are there positive things about their communities and their lives that they want to preserve?
Then the question is what are their resources to make changes. Can the community help with money or labor? Is there leadership in the community to guide the work to completion? What about long term follow up?
I try not to impose my ideas on the people I'm working with, but try to understand their concerns and offer suggestions if asked. I'm hoping rather for discussions about their interests and their ideas about solutions. I can then perhaps offer different ideas that they could consider.
We'll see how all this will go! On top of all the logistical, cultural and language barriers there will only be a short amount of time to actually talk to people and listen to their ideas. I expect that I will get far more out of the visit than the people I meet. Hopefully I'll be able to bring back some ideas and perhaps develop some ideas for future projects.
In addition to working and report writing, I'll try to maintain this blog of my activities and I'll be happy to hear opinions from you about what I'm doing. You can also check out my Agua Pura website at http://aguapuraparaelpueblo.org/
watertestingTom
Sunday, April 18, 2010
Sand Filtration Systems
Sand Filtration Systems
Recently I have been studying and writing about various methods for disinfection of water . Since I first learned about solar stoves, I have made a number of them in different designs and have also given several workshops about how to make them. Solar stoves have the capacity to heat water to temperatures adequate for Pasteurization, and small temperature indicators can verify that. Of all the methods available this one of the few that has a secure endpoint, positive proof that each batch of water has been disinfected. Other methods can only assume that the water is safe, based on previous experience. Dr. Metcalf who developed the testing methods I advocate calls this “evidence based versus faith based methodologies”.
Sand filtration systems are in this category. When working correctly they are effective and produce a fair volume of water. They have many possible defects however and require proper setup and maintenance to work safely.
One organization, Aqua Clara, has designed a small sand filtration system that seems simple enough and inexpensive enough to be used by families . It is designed to be constructed in a plastic garbage can or similar sized container, and uses PVC pipe for the internal piping. At the bottom of the container is a layer of gravel or small stones, larger than the hole sizes in the pickup tube running across the bottom. Above that layer is one of finer gravel. On top of that second layer is a thin layer of a metallic biocide, a material that kills bacteria. Finally, above that is a layer of fine sand. Thus there are at least 4 layers from bottom to top of increasingly fine sand material. In practice a layer of active bacteria and yeasts slowly forms on the surface of the sand, called a “schmutdecke” in German. This bioactive layer also helps to kill or inactivate pathogenic organisms.

The principal of the sand filter is that contaminated material slowly passes down through the schmutdecke and the very fine sand and the contaminants get trapped in the pores and interstitial spaces between the sand grains. There is also some biological activity killing pathogens in the sand layer. Any pathogenic materials that make it through the sand layers are killed when they pass through the biocide layer. Finally water pressure from above forces the clean, decontaminated water up and out the outlet pipe.
Aqua Clara suggests that the sand layers be put down very evenly and carefully so that no small channels develop through the sand, thus allowing the water to pass though without being filtered adequately. Operating properly they say it should take up to 24 hours for water to filter from the top to the bottom. Also, to be effective it make take several weeks for the bioactive schmutdecke to develop and the water may not be completely decontaminated or safe until that time.
After studying the informational material provided by Aqua Clara, I decided to try and make a small sand filter model that would demonstrate the principal of the system. I wanted something that I could take with me as an example for people to examine. I also wanted to test the methods of construction that Aqua Clara use to make their filters. After learning and practicing their procedures by making a model, I planned then to make a full size filter similar to theirs and test it for effectiveness.

I had some coarse sand from previous projects so I made two sifting screens similar to Aqua Clara's instructions and sifted the sand into three sizes: small gravel, course and fine sand. After sieving the sand into the three sizes I washed the sand to remove dirt and impurities. The procedure is to take small quantities of sand and swirl them in water for a few seconds then pour off the dirty water while the sand settles back to the bottom. Usually several washes are required to get the sand reasonably clean. The sand is then spread out to dry on clean plastic tarps.

Because of all the sand and water, these filter systems are very heavy and difficult to move, so mine was made in a small waste basket, but when completed it still weighed over 30 pounds. I cut the front panel out of the waste basket and added a
piece of Plexiglas so people could
see the different layers inside. I
then cut and fitted ½ inch PVC pipe
to make the pickup tube and outlet
pipe.
It's important to place the layers carefully in the filter so that no air is trapped and the layers are even and well packed. Starting with the gravel layer on the bottom I placed the material around the pickup tube so that the openings were not blocked. After several inches of gravel came the layer of coarse sand. In practice these layers are put in with lots of water and stirred to settle so that no air is trapped and no channels develop through the sand. I didn't have any metallic biocide material, so I put in a thin layer of white sand to indicate that material. The final fine sand layer extends up to within an inch or two of the outlet tube so that the water level remains above the sand and the sand cannot dry out.
Due to weather and other commitments this whole project took me several weeks to complete, but turned out pretty well when done. My goal was to have it ready by the time of the World Water Day activities in Portland, I was scheduled to give a presentation and I wanted the filter for a display. I made up an exhibit that included the water filter and a solar reflector oven and some other things with explanations and I thought it went pretty well.
One small problem with the filter was that the different layers tended to sift together, especially when I moved the filter. In normal operation that would not be an issue, especially if the layers were well settled, but in this case where the layers are visible they don't look as clean and distinct. If I redo this filter or make another for display, perhaps I can put something like plastic wrap in between the layers to keep them separate.
Another issue is its weight of about 40 pounds. Maybe I could make a smaller filter that isn't so heavy or substitute some other lighter material for the sand, or I could just have a nice picture of the layers and have the filter itself empty.
My next goal is to make a full size filter in a large garbage can similar to the ones made by Aqua Clara. They are quite specific about every detail of the construction so I'll try to follow their instructions closely. I have a power-point of one of their training sessions so I can try to watch it as I work. I want to build it in my back yard and use rainwater from my roof to charge it. Originally I had planned to make it a simple system that just passed the rainwater directly through the filter, but Aqua Clara says the water has to be added slowly every twelve hours, so I guess I'll have to have a rainwater storage tank that I can then pipe to the filter at intervals. I'll try to build it this summer during the dry season so that it will be ready by next fall.
Aqua Clara International has been very helpful to me, sharing their methodologies and giving me the biocide material to test and use. There are other manufacturers of water filter systems, but Aqua Clara seems committed to designing systems that local communities can build and maintain for themselves and to transferring the technology to them. I appreciate their concept and I hope that I can support them in their work. This should be a really interesting project to complete for me. I'm anxious to see how it works and to test it for a while here at home. It's important to use things yourself that you advocate for others; to practice what you preach. Just as I've used and tried to improve the latrines I've built and cooked and drank the water from the stoves I've made, I want to build and use water filters before I promote them to others.
Recently I have been studying and writing about various methods for disinfection of water . Since I first learned about solar stoves, I have made a number of them in different designs and have also given several workshops about how to make them. Solar stoves have the capacity to heat water to temperatures adequate for Pasteurization, and small temperature indicators can verify that. Of all the methods available this one of the few that has a secure endpoint, positive proof that each batch of water has been disinfected. Other methods can only assume that the water is safe, based on previous experience. Dr. Metcalf who developed the testing methods I advocate calls this “evidence based versus faith based methodologies”.
Sand filtration systems are in this category. When working correctly they are effective and produce a fair volume of water. They have many possible defects however and require proper setup and maintenance to work safely.
One organization, Aqua Clara, has designed a small sand filtration system that seems simple enough and inexpensive enough to be used by families . It is designed to be constructed in a plastic garbage can or similar sized container, and uses PVC pipe for the internal piping. At the bottom of the container is a layer of gravel or small stones, larger than the hole sizes in the pickup tube running across the bottom. Above that layer is one of finer gravel. On top of that second layer is a thin layer of a metallic biocide, a material that kills bacteria. Finally, above that is a layer of fine sand. Thus there are at least 4 layers from bottom to top of increasingly fine sand material. In practice a layer of active bacteria and yeasts slowly forms on the surface of the sand, called a “schmutdecke” in German. This bioactive layer also helps to kill or inactivate pathogenic organisms.

The principal of the sand filter is that contaminated material slowly passes down through the schmutdecke and the very fine sand and the contaminants get trapped in the pores and interstitial spaces between the sand grains. There is also some biological activity killing pathogens in the sand layer. Any pathogenic materials that make it through the sand layers are killed when they pass through the biocide layer. Finally water pressure from above forces the clean, decontaminated water up and out the outlet pipe.
Aqua Clara suggests that the sand layers be put down very evenly and carefully so that no small channels develop through the sand, thus allowing the water to pass though without being filtered adequately. Operating properly they say it should take up to 24 hours for water to filter from the top to the bottom. Also, to be effective it make take several weeks for the bioactive schmutdecke to develop and the water may not be completely decontaminated or safe until that time.
After studying the informational material provided by Aqua Clara, I decided to try and make a small sand filter model that would demonstrate the principal of the system. I wanted something that I could take with me as an example for people to examine. I also wanted to test the methods of construction that Aqua Clara use to make their filters. After learning and practicing their procedures by making a model, I planned then to make a full size filter similar to theirs and test it for effectiveness.
I had some coarse sand from previous projects so I made two sifting screens similar to Aqua Clara's instructions and sifted the sand into three sizes: small gravel, course and fine sand. After sieving the sand into the three sizes I washed the sand to remove dirt and impurities. The procedure is to take small quantities of sand and swirl them in water for a few seconds then pour off the dirty water while the sand settles back to the bottom. Usually several washes are required to get the sand reasonably clean. The sand is then spread out to dry on clean plastic tarps.
Because of all the sand and water, these filter systems are very heavy and difficult to move, so mine was made in a small waste basket, but when completed it still weighed over 30 pounds. I cut the front panel out of the waste basket and added a
piece of Plexiglas so people could
see the different layers inside. I
then cut and fitted ½ inch PVC pipe
to make the pickup tube and outlet
pipe.
It's important to place the layers carefully in the filter so that no air is trapped and the layers are even and well packed. Starting with the gravel layer on the bottom I placed the material around the pickup tube so that the openings were not blocked. After several inches of gravel came the layer of coarse sand. In practice these layers are put in with lots of water and stirred to settle so that no air is trapped and no channels develop through the sand. I didn't have any metallic biocide material, so I put in a thin layer of white sand to indicate that material. The final fine sand layer extends up to within an inch or two of the outlet tube so that the water level remains above the sand and the sand cannot dry out.
Due to weather and other commitments this whole project took me several weeks to complete, but turned out pretty well when done. My goal was to have it ready by the time of the World Water Day activities in Portland, I was scheduled to give a presentation and I wanted the filter for a display. I made up an exhibit that included the water filter and a solar reflector oven and some other things with explanations and I thought it went pretty well.
One small problem with the filter was that the different layers tended to sift together, especially when I moved the filter. In normal operation that would not be an issue, especially if the layers were well settled, but in this case where the layers are visible they don't look as clean and distinct. If I redo this filter or make another for display, perhaps I can put something like plastic wrap in between the layers to keep them separate.
Another issue is its weight of about 40 pounds. Maybe I could make a smaller filter that isn't so heavy or substitute some other lighter material for the sand, or I could just have a nice picture of the layers and have the filter itself empty.
My next goal is to make a full size filter in a large garbage can similar to the ones made by Aqua Clara. They are quite specific about every detail of the construction so I'll try to follow their instructions closely. I have a power-point of one of their training sessions so I can try to watch it as I work. I want to build it in my back yard and use rainwater from my roof to charge it. Originally I had planned to make it a simple system that just passed the rainwater directly through the filter, but Aqua Clara says the water has to be added slowly every twelve hours, so I guess I'll have to have a rainwater storage tank that I can then pipe to the filter at intervals. I'll try to build it this summer during the dry season so that it will be ready by next fall.
Aqua Clara International has been very helpful to me, sharing their methodologies and giving me the biocide material to test and use. There are other manufacturers of water filter systems, but Aqua Clara seems committed to designing systems that local communities can build and maintain for themselves and to transferring the technology to them. I appreciate their concept and I hope that I can support them in their work. This should be a really interesting project to complete for me. I'm anxious to see how it works and to test it for a while here at home. It's important to use things yourself that you advocate for others; to practice what you preach. Just as I've used and tried to improve the latrines I've built and cooked and drank the water from the stoves I've made, I want to build and use water filters before I promote them to others.
Tuesday, December 8, 2009
Monday, December 7, 2009
Professor Sergio Palleroni
This is the second lecture I have recently attended on design and innovation for the third world. The first was by Dr. Paul Polak on November 12, and I wrote about it earlier.
On Thursday, December 3rd I went to a talk by Sergio Palleroni at Mercy Corps headquarters here in Portland. He's an architect, professor, and fellow at the Center for Sustainable Practices and Processes at Portland State University. His bio on Wikipedia covers a number of years working with the UN, World Bank and other organizations world wide in development programs. He's taught at several universities including the U. of Washington and U. of Texas at Austin and written a number of articles on development. He is a founder of Basic Initiatives, an organization that sends students to underdeveloped areas around the world for intensive work helping to design and build projects in local communities. The students often are in architectural and engineering programs so the emphasis of their work is in design and functionality. They have a strong interest in environmental issues and that is a large part of their design effort as well, including the use of recycled and reusable materials and conservation.
The students typically spend several months working in the communities, helping to design and develop the projects. The process is collaborative, what Professor Palleroni calls “envisioning”, where the community members describe what they want and interact with the students and instructors to design it. He says that the normal power structure in the community is often hierarchical, with the government and authorities on the top and the disenfranchised community members on the bottom. His method is participatory instead and all interested groups including parents, neighbors and local people can all contribute. This can take some time as ideas are presented and discussed and modified. The process is completely transparent with final decisions being made by consensus.
One example he gave was of a school they built in a squatter community in Mexico. What started out as a request for some ideas over a number of years became a model school with modern design features and a strong environmental focus. It features natural lighting, solar heating and cooling and water conservation and recycling. It now includes a kitchen with a solar cooker to make meals for the students and a community center and community gardens. The people also wanted a wedding chapel so that they could have proper ceremonies and that is there as well.
Professor Palleroni gave other examples of their projects around the world, including work in Taiwan and Nepal. They also worked in New Orleans after Katrina helping to develop hurricane resistant housing that met building codes. He says that he always designs things that meet local codes and standards so that others in the future can use his ideas to do the same thing. They also developed industries using recycled lumber from the flooded houses to make furniture.
He has a tradition of looking at the situation around him, in this case Portland, Oregon. He noted that Portland has some of the oldest schools in the country, including 59 according to him that need complete replacement or rebuilding. He is starting a process to involve local communities in Portland to adopt their neighborhood school and start working to improve or rebuild them. He says the first step will be “visioning” where people talk about what they would like their local schools to be like. It will be interesting to see what impact his ideas have here in Portland.
One thing I don't like about my own work is that the groups I have been working with don't have much say in the planning and preparation of their projects. Basically, someone else decides what will be done and plans the work so that we just show up with our money and work for a few days. The projects are designed to be quick and cheap, what we can afford and what can be accomplished in the short time we have. I rarely have a sense of a long term plan in the work. How much community input or ideas are included is not very clear.
Some people like that schedule however. They often don't have a lot of spare time, perhaps taking vacation to participate. They also like the hands on aspect of working hard on a short term project they can complete in one visit. Hard physical work is also a way to demonstrate their personal commitment. They can then return home with a clear conscience and perhaps participate in some other project somewhere else the next time.
To be fair, some groups and leaders have developed their own long term relationships with the communities they serve. Roger Capps group spent over 10 years working at Tultitlan in Mexico and managed to build a school and a community center there over that time. The friendships they developed over the years helped them to make the more long term commitments necessary to complete that project. Other leaders, while taking new groups each time, often have their own relationships with local community members. Even still though, I often find the short term nature of the work personally dissatisfying.
It would be gratifying to some time to just visit in a community and talk to people about their ideas, their problems and their aspirations, “visioning” with them. Up to now most of the planning and scheduling for our trips is done in advance, here in the States. Our time is already committed, sometimes by other people before we ever arrive, and any talking or visiting sort of goes against the schedule. For some “hands on” type of people this schedule would be a frustrating waste of time, but it would be very satisfying to me. It would also give me a better sense of the true interests of the people of the community, and if future projects, short or long term, developed because of this I'd feel better thinking that they came from what people wanted and not just what we could get done in a week.
On Thursday, December 3rd I went to a talk by Sergio Palleroni at Mercy Corps headquarters here in Portland. He's an architect, professor, and fellow at the Center for Sustainable Practices and Processes at Portland State University. His bio on Wikipedia covers a number of years working with the UN, World Bank and other organizations world wide in development programs. He's taught at several universities including the U. of Washington and U. of Texas at Austin and written a number of articles on development. He is a founder of Basic Initiatives, an organization that sends students to underdeveloped areas around the world for intensive work helping to design and build projects in local communities. The students often are in architectural and engineering programs so the emphasis of their work is in design and functionality. They have a strong interest in environmental issues and that is a large part of their design effort as well, including the use of recycled and reusable materials and conservation.
The students typically spend several months working in the communities, helping to design and develop the projects. The process is collaborative, what Professor Palleroni calls “envisioning”, where the community members describe what they want and interact with the students and instructors to design it. He says that the normal power structure in the community is often hierarchical, with the government and authorities on the top and the disenfranchised community members on the bottom. His method is participatory instead and all interested groups including parents, neighbors and local people can all contribute. This can take some time as ideas are presented and discussed and modified. The process is completely transparent with final decisions being made by consensus.
One example he gave was of a school they built in a squatter community in Mexico. What started out as a request for some ideas over a number of years became a model school with modern design features and a strong environmental focus. It features natural lighting, solar heating and cooling and water conservation and recycling. It now includes a kitchen with a solar cooker to make meals for the students and a community center and community gardens. The people also wanted a wedding chapel so that they could have proper ceremonies and that is there as well.
Professor Palleroni gave other examples of their projects around the world, including work in Taiwan and Nepal. They also worked in New Orleans after Katrina helping to develop hurricane resistant housing that met building codes. He says that he always designs things that meet local codes and standards so that others in the future can use his ideas to do the same thing. They also developed industries using recycled lumber from the flooded houses to make furniture.
He has a tradition of looking at the situation around him, in this case Portland, Oregon. He noted that Portland has some of the oldest schools in the country, including 59 according to him that need complete replacement or rebuilding. He is starting a process to involve local communities in Portland to adopt their neighborhood school and start working to improve or rebuild them. He says the first step will be “visioning” where people talk about what they would like their local schools to be like. It will be interesting to see what impact his ideas have here in Portland.
One thing I don't like about my own work is that the groups I have been working with don't have much say in the planning and preparation of their projects. Basically, someone else decides what will be done and plans the work so that we just show up with our money and work for a few days. The projects are designed to be quick and cheap, what we can afford and what can be accomplished in the short time we have. I rarely have a sense of a long term plan in the work. How much community input or ideas are included is not very clear.
Some people like that schedule however. They often don't have a lot of spare time, perhaps taking vacation to participate. They also like the hands on aspect of working hard on a short term project they can complete in one visit. Hard physical work is also a way to demonstrate their personal commitment. They can then return home with a clear conscience and perhaps participate in some other project somewhere else the next time.
To be fair, some groups and leaders have developed their own long term relationships with the communities they serve. Roger Capps group spent over 10 years working at Tultitlan in Mexico and managed to build a school and a community center there over that time. The friendships they developed over the years helped them to make the more long term commitments necessary to complete that project. Other leaders, while taking new groups each time, often have their own relationships with local community members. Even still though, I often find the short term nature of the work personally dissatisfying.
It would be gratifying to some time to just visit in a community and talk to people about their ideas, their problems and their aspirations, “visioning” with them. Up to now most of the planning and scheduling for our trips is done in advance, here in the States. Our time is already committed, sometimes by other people before we ever arrive, and any talking or visiting sort of goes against the schedule. For some “hands on” type of people this schedule would be a frustrating waste of time, but it would be very satisfying to me. It would also give me a better sense of the true interests of the people of the community, and if future projects, short or long term, developed because of this I'd feel better thinking that they came from what people wanted and not just what we could get done in a week.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
